Nathan Barkley, P.E. Nathan Barkley, P.E.

Design by Rule vs. Design by Analysis: Which ASME Section VIII Path Is Right for Your Vessel?

Design by Rule or Design by Analysis? For an ASME Section VIII vessel, the answer isn't "simple engineering vs. sophisticated engineering." The real question: do the applicable code rules adequately represent the design problem, and will additional analysis support a better, defensible decision?

In my latest article I walk through:

• When Division 1 Design by Rules is the right (and more economical) path
• When Division 2 Design by Analysis is actually warranted, and when it's overkill (or prohibited)
• The two places DBA results most often get misread: stress classification lines and nozzle reinforcement checks
• A practical 5-question decision sequence before committing to either path

The goal is the simplest defensible path, not the most analysis.

Read More
Nathan Barkley, P.E. Nathan Barkley, P.E.

Making Non-ASME Stamped Vessels Legal—and Safe—in the U.S.

In U.S. plants, the default assumption is simple: if it’s a pressure vessel, it was built and stamped to ASME Section VIII, Division 1. That’s what most state laws require, and it’s the baseline most owner/operators work from. When equipment is not U-stamped, you’re typically looking at an exception process—often called a “State Special”—to secure installation or continued operation.

This post distills a recent conference paper into a field-ready playbook. We’ll unpack the regulatory context, then walk through two case studies: (1) importing CE-marked (PED) vessels and (2) securing approval for an older, non-code flare drum that now sees higher pressure. Along the way you’ll see what evidence actually convinces a state board and chief inspector, and how to set yourself up for a smoother approval.

Read More

Need Specialized Engineering Support?

Whether you're solving an urgent equipment issue, supplementing your engineering team, or tackling a complex pressure vessel project, we're ready to help.

To contact us directly via email:

operations@refinedengineering.com

Business office:

+1 (662) 486-9795